If you’ve found yourself completing one of our masterful reviews and wanting additional clarification on our scoring logic, you’ve come to the right place. The breakdown below will give you insight into the wizard-like thought process that goes into our review score generation. Please make sure to draw the curtain shut once you’ve finished. Enjoy.
1 (RIP) to 4 are varying degrees of a bad game. A 1 (RIP) being a game you would actually pay money to not play, and a 4 is something that just fails to reach even the not-so-lofty level of “mediocre.”
5 and 5.5 are mediocre. These aren’t necessarily bad games, they just don’t do anything that is worth caring about and not worth the time of most people.
6 and 6.5 represent a game that doesn’t do anything spectacular or drastically fails to meet the high expectations people had for it. These scores are for games that you would only recommend to diehard fans of the series or genre, something that the average gamer wouldn’t miss very much if he/she skipped it. A game in this range has rental written all over it.
7 and 7.5 represent a game that overall manages to be worth a playthrough, just not worth the full price at launch. These scores are for games that are relatively good or even really good, but generally worth waiting for a sale or picking up as a rental when possible.
8 and 8.5 represent a game that is a good experience overall. While there may be some issues that prevent it from being fantastic, these scores are for games that you feel would easily be worth a purchase.
9 and 9.5 represent the pinnacle of the genre, a game that defines what that genre should be about. These scores are for games that you not only feel would be worth your purchase, but you would actually try to convince your friends to buy them as well.
10 (TEN) represents a game that you would unequivocally recommend to all gamers. This score is reserved for games you consider to be not only the best of their genre, but to be one of the best games of the year. A 10 does not have to be absolutey perfect — we do NOT hold games up to an impossible standard because that simply is not fair. Ebert and Roeper did not give 1 and 9/10ths thumbs up.
In even simpler terms:
1 (RIP)-4: Varying degrees of badness
5: Who cares
6-6.5: Fanboys only
7-7.5: Rent it
8-8.5: Buy it
9-9.5: Kill for it
10 (TEN): Worship it
If you have any further questions feel free to contact us at Editors@RipTen.com